BUSINESS
Colman’s Went on Sale, but the CMA Wants the Mixes
The CMA cleared mustard after Unilever shopped Colman’s, and now wants a dry-mix fix on the McCormick Foods deal by 18 November.
Britain’s Competition and Markets Authority has given Unilever and McCormick until 18 November 2026 to offer remedies on their Foods merger, or it will open a Phase 2 inquiry.
The Phase 1 finding, published on 11 November, sits in dry ingredient mixes and dry sauces sold to UK retailers. Mustard, the overlap Unilever had already put up for sale, was cleared.
An 18 November Deadline on a $44.8 Billion Deal
The watchdog’s CMA McCormick Unilever case file is still open. It opened with an invitation to comment on 21 July 2026, launched a formal inquiry on 16 September, and on 11 November said the combination will be referred for an in-depth investigation unless the parties offer an acceptable undertaking.
That clock is now short. The CMA has found a realistic prospect of a substantial lessening of competition in two UK grocery lines, and it will move to Phase 2 if no undertaking is offered or if what is offered is judged too weak. The full decision text is due to be published shortly; the public case already sets the next date in stone.
HOW THE UK REVIEW HAS MOVED
- 31 March 2026: Unilever and McCormick announce a combination of Unilever Foods with McCormick, with completion aimed at mid-2027.
- 21 July 2026: The CMA invites comments on the UK impact of the deal, with that window closing on 5 August.
- 27 August 2026: Unilever says it will market the Colman’s brand and assets to potential buyers to address competition concerns.
- 16 September 2026: The CMA launches its formal merger inquiry.
- 26 October 2026: The Dutch ACM refuses permission for Unilever’s sale of Unox to Zwanenberg.
- 11 November 2026: The CMA publishes its Phase 1 finding and sets an 18 November deadline for undertakings.
McCormick, the Maryland spice group, has agreed to take substantially all of Unilever’s global food business, including Knorr and Hellmann’s. Some Unilever food units stay behind, among them Lipton drinks, the lifestyle nutrition business, Buavita, and operations in India, Nepal and Portugal. The CMA says it has jurisdiction because the UK turnover of each of McCormick and Unilever Foods exceeds £100 million.
Mustard Was the Wrong Sacrifice
On 27 August Unilever said a decision had been taken to market the Colman’s brand and assets to potential buyers “in order to proactively seek to address potential competition concerns from the planned combination of Unilever Foods and McCormick.” Colman’s, founded in 1814, sits beside McCormick’s French’s mustard in British condiment aisles, and that pairing looked like the obvious clash.
The CMA then looked at mustard on its own and cleared it. McCormick supplies American-style mustard under French’s. Unilever supplies English-style mustard under Colman’s and French-style mustard under Maille. Evidence from large supermarkets, the watchdog said, showed that shoppers typically do not treat those styles as suitable alternatives to one another, so retailers need to stock each type.
Because the CMA found little meaningful competition between the styles, it treated them as separate product markets and found no overlap between the parties’ mustard lines. No retailer raised a concern that the merged group would use power in one mustard type to hurt rivals in another. The mustard file is closed. The Colman’s auction may yet change who owns a famous British jar; it did not retire the finding the CMA actually made.
Schwartz and Knorr Share the Mix Aisle
The live problem is much less famous than mustard and much harder to wave away. In the UK, McCormick sells dry ingredient mixes and sauces under Schwartz. Unilever Foods sells in the same shops under Knorr, Colman’s and Maille. The CMA’s Phase 1 decision summary says the merger would combine the two largest branded suppliers of dry cooking ingredient mixes, such as chilli con carne, and of dry pour-over sauces, such as parsley sauce.
The merged group, the CMA found, would be the largest supplier in both categories by far. The parties are close competitors in those lines. The watchdog reviewed submissions, information requests, the companies’ own internal documents, and evidence from customers and rivals before it reached that view.
WHERE THE CMA DREW THE LINE
| UK grocery line | McCormick | Unilever Foods | Phase 1 outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry ingredient mixes (e.g. chilli con carne) | Schwartz | Knorr, Colman’s, Maille UK set | SLC risk; two largest brands; largest by far |
| Dry pour-over sauces (e.g. parsley sauce) | Schwartz | Knorr, Colman’s, Maille UK set | SLC risk; two largest brands; largest by far |
| American-style mustard | French’s | None in this style | No SLC; separate market |
| English-style mustard | None in this style | Colman’s | No SLC; separate market |
| French-style mustard | None in this style | Maille | No SLC; separate market |
Those mix and sauce packets are a thin slice of a global Foods combination, and they are the slice that can still force a UK asset sale. A Phase 1 remedy has to fix both lines, because the CMA recorded them as separate substantial lessening of competition findings, not as one bundled grocery worry.
Why Maggi and Bisto Do Not Clear It
Unilever and McCormick can point to other names on the same shelves. The CMA named them, then discounted them. Nestlé’s Maggi competes in dry ingredient mixes. Premier Foods’ Bisto competes in dry sauces. Supermarket own-label sits in both. None of that, the watchdog said, is enough.
WHY THE CMA SAYS RIVALS WILL NOT HOLD THE MERGED GROUP
- Weak branded checks: Maggi in mixes and Bisto in sauces exert some pressure, yet the CMA called that constraint limited, along with other branded suppliers and other product types.
- Own-label is not a full substitute: Private label exerts some pressure too, and still, in the CMA’s words, imposes only a limited constraint on the parties in both lines.
- Shelf space is scarce: Entry and expansion are hard because supermarket shelf space is limited and existing suppliers, in particular the parties and private label, are well established.
- No growth wave to ride: The CMA has not seen significant growth in the relevant product markets that would suggest new entry or expansion would constrain the merged entity.
That is a grocery finding, not a branding one. If the merged group can raise prices or ease off on promotions in chilli mixes and parsley sauce, the CMA does not expect Maggi, Bisto or a retailer’s own packet to take the volume back fast enough. Any undertaking has to restore a competitor the watchdog will believe in, not a promise that own-label will keep the aisle honest.
The Dutch Already Blocked Unox
The UK mix problem arrives after another European food sale already failed. On 26 October the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets decided it would give no approval for the Unox takeover by Zwanenberg Food Group. The ACM said the deal would make Zwanenberg almost the only major supplier of smoked and boiled sausages, including frankfurters, to Dutch supermarkets, and would give it too strong a position in shelf-stable soups.
Zwanenberg would have held shares of about 60 to 85 percent in those lines. Martijn Snoep, chair of the ACM, said the watchdog wanted to prevent people being confronted with higher prices as a result of the takeover, because one party would hold too strong a position in shelf-stable sausages and soups, leaving supermarkets with fewer suppliers and a risk of higher shop prices.
Zwanenberg had offered to sell some production capacity to a new buyer. The ACM judged those proposals insufficient: the intended buyer’s capacity in boiled sausages was too small, the plans were not concrete enough, and a dependence on Zwanenberg would have lasted for the first two years. Supermarkets also doubted whether the fix would work in practice. Unilever said it was very disappointed and would review the decision; a spokesperson said the company stood behind the proposal it had put forward.
The Unox block is a different country and a different product. It is also a warning about how grocery watchdogs now treat “almost the only major supplier” findings, and about how a capacity carve-out can fail if the buyer looks too small or too tied to the seller. A UK mix remedy that leaves Knorr and Schwartz under one roof, or that sells a thin package to a weak buyer, would invite the same kind of no.
A Phase 2 Inquiry Against a Mid-2027 Close
On 28 October, two days after the Dutch refusal, Unilever’s third-quarter statement said separation work was progressing well, with more than 200 staff across 20 teams, and that there had been strong progress on regulatory approvals, with filings in on schedule and “clear momentum across jurisdictions, reinforcing our confidence in a timely closing.” Closure, it repeated, still depends on McCormick shareholder approval, required regulatory approvals and other customary conditions.
The UK piece of that claim now has a date on it. CMA procedure for a Phase 2 merger inquiry runs on a 24-week statutory clock, which the watchdog can extend. The companies have aimed to complete by mid-2027. A Phase 2 reference would not by itself kill the combination, but it would park the UK clearance well into 2027 and keep a forced sale in play under a deeper review.
The Foods business being sold is not growing its way out of scrutiny. In the third quarter Unilever said Foods underlying sales grew 0.1%, with volume down 1.1 percent and price up 1.3 percent, on turnover of €3.1 billion, or 23 percent of group turnover. Cooking Aids, the bucket that holds mixes and stocks, was broadly flat. Condiments, including Hellmann’s, were broadly flat too. Group underlying sales grew 5.2 percent, with turnover of €13.3 billion, up 6.7 percent, led by home care, personal care and beauty. Foods was the laggard inside a group that is trying to leave food.
WHAT WE KNOW
- The finding: The CMA has identified a realistic prospect of SLC in dry ingredient mixes and, separately, in dry sauces to UK retailers, and has cleared mustard.
- The deadline: Unilever and McCormick have until 18 November 2026 to offer undertakings in lieu of a reference.
- The Colman’s process: Unilever has been marketing Colman’s since 27 August; that process is not, on the public record, a CMA undertaking.
- The Dutch parallel: The ACM refused the Unox sale to Zwanenberg on 26 October after judging proposed capacity remedies insufficient.
WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED
- The UK fix: Whether the companies will offer to sell Schwartz mixes, Unilever mix and sauce lines, or some other package, and whether the CMA will accept it at Phase 1.
- Colman’s perimeter: Whether a Colman’s sale, if it completes, would remove enough mix and sauce overlap to satisfy the CMA.
- Other clearances: How remaining competition reviews outside the UK will treat the same global combination.
Unilever has called the 11 November decision an expected step in the regulatory process and said it is working with the CMA on a suitable remedy. McCormick has said it continues to make good progress on approvals globally and remains confident of a timely closing. Those lines can both be true only if the UK carve-out is small, clean and fast.
Unilever Shareholders Are Due 55.1%
The combination announced on 31 March is built so that Unilever leaves most of food and still owns a slice of what remains. Unilever put an enterprise value of $44.8 billion on Unilever Foods, equal to 3.6 times sales and 13.8 times EBITDA on a one-month McCormick volume-weighted average share price of $57.84. Unilever is to receive $15.7 billion in cash, subject to closing adjustments, to cover separation and tax costs, pay debt down to about 2.0 times net debt to EBITDA, and support €6 billion of buybacks planned between 2026 and 2029.
WHAT THE COMBINATION IS DESIGNED TO PAY
| Term | Figure |
|---|---|
| Unilever Foods enterprise value | $44.8 billion |
| Cash to Unilever at close | $15.7 billion |
| Equity value attributed to Unilever and its shareholders | $29.1 billion (65.0 percent) |
| Unilever shareholders | 55.1 percent |
| Unilever retained stake | 9.9 percent, with a sell-down intended no earlier than one year after closing |
| McCormick shareholders | 35.0 percent |
| Combined revenue, fiscal 2025 | $20 billion |
| Run-rate cost synergies, by end of year three | about $600 million, with $100 million extra reinvested in growth |
| Targeted completion | mid-2027 |
The combined company keeps the McCormick name, its Hunt Valley, Maryland headquarters and its New York listing, and plans an international headquarters in the Netherlands plus a secondary listing in Europe. It will be led by McCormick chief executive Brendan Foley and chief financial officer Marcos Gabriel, with senior Unilever Foods managers in the team. After the split, Unilever would be a home, beauty and personal care group with €39 billion of fiscal 2025 revenue.
We are unlocking trapped value through a growth-led separation of Foods, creating a scaled, global flavour powerhouse.
Fernando Fernandez, Chief Executive Officer, Unilever, 31 March 2026 announcement
A UK sale of mix and sauce brands would nick that powerhouse at the margin. It would not rewrite the 55.1 percent Unilever shareholders are due, the 9.9 percent Unilever plans to hold, or Foley’s seat. It would decide whether chilli mix and parsley sauce stay inside that group or go to a buyer the CMA will accept before 18 November 2026, which is now the date that sits on the UK door of a mid-2027 close.
-
BUSINESS3 months agoWarsh Rejects Rate Guidance and Still Moves Markets
-
ENTERTAINMENT1 month agoDavina McCall Reveals Cardiovascular Disease After Cholesterol Warnings
-
BUSINESS2 months agoDana-Farber Exits an MGB Medicare Advantage Network Early
-
NEWS3 months agoNASA Launches the Roman Space Telescope’s Cosmic Bet
-
NEWS3 months agoOpenAI’s Cyber Letter Puts the Defense Bill on Governments
-
NEWS3 months agoRussia Recycles Its Old Warning Over Storm Shadow Plants
-
ENTERTAINMENT2 months agoPrimetime’s $2.7 Million Preview Tops Pitt’s Costlier Film
-
BUSINESS3 months agoJet Drones Lock Down Kyiv and Strip Kherson of Heat
