NEWS
ONC Cuts AI Model Cards After Hospitals Save Privacy Tests
ONC kept 13 EHR privacy tests after hospital objections, then stripped AI model cards and security tags from certified records in the HTI-5 rule.
Federal health IT officials on Oct. 26 removed 14 of 60 certification tests for electronic health records and erased AI model-card rules from the decision-support test that remains.
The Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT still kept all 13 privacy and security criteria it had proposed to delete in December 2025, after hospital technology groups warned that encryption, audit logs, and multi-factor login tests were how smaller practices showed a HIPAA floor.
ONC posted the announcement the same day.
NEW 🚨 The HTI-5 final rule is now available! It seeks to reduce burden on health IT developers by streamlining the ONC Health IT Certification Program. Learn more: https://t.co/x5vlULGEHr #HealthIT #Certification #HTI5 pic.twitter.com/ZCvNiGlJ70
— Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (@ONC_HealthIT) October 26, 2026
Hospitals Saved the Old Privacy Tests
The December 2025 proposal would have wiped every privacy and security criterion in 45 CFR 170.315(d). That is a set of 13 tests covering authentication, audit logs, encryption, automatic logoff, emergency access, and multi-factor login, plus the related certification framework under 170.550(h).
The College of Healthcare Information Management Executives told ONC to retain that baseline. In the unpublished final rule, the agency said it had retained the privacy and security criteria and the associated framework it had proposed to remove.
The rewrite is named Health Data, Technology, and Interoperability: ONC Deregulatory Actions to Unleash Prosperity, or HTI-5. It cites President Donald Trump’s Unleashing Prosperity Through Deregulation order and a later order on anti-competitive barriers.
HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. said American doctors need better technology, not more Washington paperwork, and that the administration is eliminating unnecessary regulations that cost more than $1.5 billion.
Tom Keane, M.D., the national coordinator for health IT, put the same pitch in operational terms for developers of certified products used in hospitals, including systems from vendors such as Epic and Oracle.
A successful certification program should establish the floor healthcare needs without becoming the ceiling innovation keeps hitting. HTI-5 is an important step in that direction.
Tom Keane, M.D., National Coordinator for Health IT, briefing reporters
THE HTI-5 COUNT
- Criteria removed: 14 of 60 tests leave the ONC Health IT Certification Program.
- Criteria revised: 7 tests change, including decision support interventions.
- Criteria untouched: 39 remain, including the HTI-4 prior-authorization and real-time prescription-benefit tests.
- Privacy suite: All 13 criteria in 170.315(d) stay in place.
That split is the rule’s actual shape. The old login-and-encryption checklist survived a comment fight. The newer transparency tools built for algorithms, and the labels that travel with sensitive summaries, did not.
Fourteen Criteria Leave the Certification Program
ONC removed 14 criteria and revised seven, and it left 39 as they were. The December 2025 draft had proposed to remove 34 of those 60 tests. The final package is a partial walk-back, not the reset that draft described.
WHAT ONC PROPOSED AND WHAT IT FINALIZED
| Requirement | December 2025 proposal | HTI-5 final rule |
|---|---|---|
| 13 privacy and security criteria, 170.315(d) | Remove all | Retained, no change |
| AI model cards inside decision support, 170.315(b)(11) | Remove source-attribute rules | Source-attribute rules removed |
| Security tags on care summaries, 170.315(b)(7) and (b)(8) | Remove | Removed |
| Implantable device list, 170.315(a)(14) | Remove | Kept |
| Transitions of care, 170.315(b)(1) | Revise on Jan. 1, 2027 | Revise on Jan. 1, 2030 |
Most of the 14 deletions are old document and measure functions: family health history, care-plan documents, automated numerator recording, Consolidated CDA creation performance, and both Direct Project transport tests. Two of them are not housekeeping. They are the send and receive tests for security tags on summary-of-care documents, the Data Segmentation for Privacy labels that mark a record as tagged as restricted and subject to re-disclosure at the document, section, and entry level.
The unpublished rule says a majority of commenters opposed dropping those tag tests, mainly because clinics still move records as C-CDA documents and FHIR labeling is not yet the daily path. Several commenters called the pair the only mechanism in the Certification Program for segmenting sensitive health information, including behavioral health and substance-use data.
ONC removed them anyway. The agency said certification to the tag criteria has been limited, that the tests are not in the Base EHR or CEHRT definitions, and that the industry is moving toward FHIR. Dropping a certification test does not force a vendor to rip the function out of software already in use, the preamble notes, and it does not bar anyone from keeping the standard.
Clinics that still need those tags will have to demand them in contracts, because the federal certificate will no longer prove they exist.
The Model Cards That Will Not Appear on Screen
The sharpest revision sits inside decision support interventions at 170.315(b)(11). HTI-1, finished in December 2023, had required certified products, starting Jan. 1, 2025, to support “model cards” for predictive tools. The unpublished HTI-5 text describes those cards as nutrition labels: how an algorithm was trained, its intended use and limits, and how it performs across patient groups.
HTI-5 deletes source-attribute support, source-attribute access and modification, and intervention risk management. The decision-support criterion itself remains, in a narrower form. Users can still be asked to select evidence-based and predictive tools. They will no longer have a certified screen that shows the label.
A large majority of commenters opposed that cut. They said the requirements had been in force less than two years, that stripping them would open a gap just as predictive tools spread, and that hospitals would lose intended use, provenance, training data, limits, and known risks. Some said funding-source fields help flag commercial or drug-maker influence on alerts. Others said the people who actually read the cards are governance, procurement, and safety teams, not the physician in the exam room.
ONC was not persuaded. Developers of certified health IT had reported that most clinical users lack the time or technical background to open source-attribute screens during care, the agency wrote, and it found no peer-reviewed or trade-press evidence that users had relied on the transparency rules or that the rules improved how organizations evaluate predictive tools. Oversight of clinical algorithms, in that telling, belongs more with the Food and Drug Administration and with civil-rights non-discrimination rules than with EHR certification.
The preamble leaves a door cracked. ONC said it will consider in later rulemaking whether some “source attributes transparency” elements should come back. Until then, a chief medical information officer who wants training data, validation, and version history has to ask the vendor and write the ask into the contract. Vaccine charts still carry a lot number so a bad batch can be found. Certified record systems will no longer have to carry the equivalent for a predictive tool.
Why Commenters Said the Labels Still Mattered
The comment file did not treat model cards as paperwork. Commenters described a shift of work and of legal risk from the company that built the tool to the hospital that clicked it on.
WHAT COMMENTERS SAID WOULD BREAK
- Safety review: Hospitals would have to reconstruct intended use, training data, and known limits without a certified feed from the developer.
- Bias checks: Performance across patient groups would sit behind vendor portals, if it sat anywhere.
- Sensitive care: Behavioral health and substance-use tools would be harder to use lawfully if the record no longer showed how the model handled restricted data.
- Commercial influence: Funding-source disclosures, a field on the old cards, would no longer be a certification item.
- Liability: Evaluation, governance, and malpractice exposure would move onto the provider, which is already the party named in most information-blocking complaints.
ONC’s reply is that a label unused at the bedside is a cost with no proven clinical return. That answer ignores the other desk. Safety committees and AI review boards do not work at the same pace as a clinic schedule, and they are the buyers who now have to negotiate for data the certificate once required.
Leigh Burchell of Altera Digital Health, chair of the EHR Association, said member companies were still reading the unpublished text and were pleased the agency had taken several of their recommendations, including the decision not to finish the information-blocking rewrite in this package.
Developer Savings Hit $1.55 Billion on Paper
The unpublished rule’s impact analysis claims present-value savings of $1.55 billion and $108.1 million in annualized net savings, in 2024 dollars, discounted at 7 percent, beginning in 2027 and counted in perpetuity. Those dollars measure time and effort that developers of certified health IT would have spent if the deleted tests had stayed in force. They are not a hospital budget line.
Keane told reporters the practical effect is to free developer time for interoperability, automation, and clinician-facing tools. Kennedy’s “more than $1.5 billion” line is the same present-value figure spoken in round numbers.
ONC also trimmed maintenance duties around the certificate. Real-world testing plans are scaled back. Insights reporting is cut in line with an April 29, 2025, enforcement discretion, except that the FHIR bulk-data-access measure stays. Public listing of FHIR service base URLs remains, after the agency rejected a vendor request to drop it. Quality-management and accessibility-centered design criteria were not among the 14 deletions.
The implantable device list, which the draft would have removed, stays so hospitals can still attest to CMS’s unique-device-identifier measure. Family health history leaves on Jan. 1, 2027, a date ONC set so CMS can update its own definitions. The certificate is being aligned with payment rules, not only with a deregulatory order.
Information Blocking Stays in the Next Rule
HTI-5 is also a demolition job on document-era tests, meant to clear space for FHIR APIs and, in the preamble’s language, “super intelligence” tools that can sit on those APIs, including emerging context protocols for large language models. Direct Project transport leaves at the rule’s effective date. Transitions of care, the C-CDA path that small clinics, post-acute sites, and behavioral health still use, is revised on Jan. 1, 2030, four years later than the draft’s 2027 date.
The information-blocking chapter from the December 2025 proposal is not in this final. HHS said those comments remain under consideration. The draft would have spelled out that “access” and “use” include automated means, including autonomous AI systems, and would have revised several exceptions. Michael Lipinski, ONC’s regulatory affairs division director, told reporters the agency could still finish those proposals from the existing record or start a new comment round.
Keane said HHS is still working with the HHS Office of Inspector General on information-blocking cases. The enforcement posture, he said, has not changed.
THE HTI CALENDAR
- December 2023: HTI-1 adds algorithm transparency, including model-card source attributes, to certified decision support.
- Jan. 1, 2025: Those source-attribute duties take effect; the older clinical decision support test expires.
- Oct. 1, 2025: HTI-4, issued with the FY 2026 inpatient payment rule, adds electronic prior authorization and real-time prescription-benefit tests.
- Dec. 22, 2025: ONC proposes HTI-5, aiming to remove 34 of 60 criteria, including all 13 privacy and security tests and the model cards.
- Feb. 27, 2026: The 60-day comment period closes.
- Oct. 26, 2026: ONC releases the HTI-5 final rule, cutting 14 criteria and the model cards, and keeping the privacy suite.
- Oct. 28, 2026: The rule is scheduled for Federal Register publication; an ONC information session is set for Oct. 29.
- Dec. 27, 2026: Most removals and revisions take effect, 60 days after publication; seven wait until Jan. 1, 2027, and transitions of care wait until Jan. 1, 2030.
The certificate that hospitals buy will still say the old privacy tests were passed. It will no longer say a predictive tool came with a label, or that a care summary can carry a restriction tag the next hospital is certified to honor. That is the bargain HTI-5 closed, and it is the one the next rule will have to reopen if ONC wants those labels back.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did the HTI-5 Rule Remove HIPAA Duties for Hospitals?
No. HIPAA’s Privacy and Security Rules still apply to covered entities and business associates. The 13 ONC privacy and security certification criteria are a separate, voluntary product test, and the unpublished rule repeats an older warning: buying software certified to those criteria does not, by itself, make a hospital HIPAA-compliant. HTI-5 leaves those 13 product tests in place after proposing to delete them. Encryption, audit logs, and multi-factor login remain items a vendor can still put on a certificate.
What Is an AI Model Card in EHR Certification?
Under HTI-1, a model card was the set of source attributes a certified product had to make available for predictive decision-support tools, described in HTI-5 as a nutrition label covering training, intended use, limits, and performance across groups. HTI-5 removes the duties to support, display, and maintain those attributes and to run intervention risk management, while keeping a narrower decision-support criterion. ONC said it may restore some source-attribute elements in a later rule. Until then, a buyer who wants the label has to bargain for it.
When Does the HTI-5 Final Rule Take Effect?
The unpublished text is scheduled for the Federal Register on Oct. 28, 2026, and most amendments take effect 60 days later, on Dec. 27, 2026. Amendatory instructions 7, 10, and 12 wait until Jan. 1, 2027, which is also when family health history, quality-measure filtering, patient health-information capture, automated measure tests, and two older application-access tests leave. The transitions-of-care revision is dated Jan. 1, 2030. ONC’s criteria table is the checklist vendors will use to time engineering work.
Are Security Tags Part of Certified EHR Technology for CMS?
They are not. The send and receive security-tag criteria were never in the Base EHR definition or in CMS’s CEHRT definition, which is one reason ONC gave for deleting them. They were the Certification Program’s only tests for Data Segmentation for Privacy labels on C-CDA summaries. After the effective date, a hospital that needs those tags for behavioral health, HIV, or substance-use records will have to specify them in a contract, because the federal certificate will not.
What Happens Next With Information Blocking?
Nothing in HTI-5 changes the current information-blocking rule. Comments on the December 2025 proposals, including a plan to state that automated and autonomous AI access counts as “access” and “use,” remain under review. Lipinski said ONC could finish those proposals from the existing comment file or issue a new proposed rule. Keane said work with the inspector general continues. A later HTI package is expected to pick up APIs, successor standards, and those blocking files.
Disclaimer: This article is news reporting on a federal health information technology rule and is for information only. It is not legal, medical, compliance, or certification advice, and it does not tell hospitals, software vendors, or patients how to meet HIPAA, CMS Promoting Interoperability, or ONC certification duties. Anyone who must change a product, a contract, or a clinical workflow because of HTI-5 should consult qualified health-law counsel, a certified health IT specialist, and the rule text ONC publishes in the Federal Register. Figures, criteria lists, and effective dates reflect the unpublished final rule and agency materials cited here and may change when the official Register version appears or in later rulemaking.
-
BUSINESS3 months agoWarsh Rejects Rate Guidance and Still Moves Markets
-
ENTERTAINMENT1 month agoDavina McCall Reveals Cardiovascular Disease After Cholesterol Warnings
-
BUSINESS2 months agoDana-Farber Exits an MGB Medicare Advantage Network Early
-
NEWS3 months agoNASA Launches the Roman Space Telescope’s Cosmic Bet
-
NEWS3 months agoOpenAI’s Cyber Letter Puts the Defense Bill on Governments
-
NEWS3 months agoRussia Recycles Its Old Warning Over Storm Shadow Plants
-
ENTERTAINMENT2 months agoPrimetime’s $2.7 Million Preview Tops Pitt’s Costlier Film
-
BUSINESS3 months agoJet Drones Lock Down Kyiv and Strip Kherson of Heat
