Connect with us

BUSINESS

A 1930 Brooklyn Building Fell Into the Next-Door Pit

Eight died when 1321 Flatbush Avenue slid into a foundation pit whose own files had already flagged a poor north wall, underpinning, and movement limits.

Published

on

A three-story building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn fell into an open construction pit at 4:01 p.m. on November 11, killing eight people. Fire and EMS units responded within one minute, and more than 250 firefighters and EMS workers worked the pile through the night.

The FDNY ended the search just after 4 p.m. on November 12. Eighteen people were hurt, including four firefighters. The 1930 walk-up had sat on the lip of an excavation at 2625 Bedford Avenue, on a lot whose own paperwork had already treated the wall next door as a risk.

1321 Flatbush Avenue Fell Into the Lot Next Door

Fire Commissioner Lillian Bonsignore called it a major technical response at a three-story multiple dwelling that collapsed into an adjacent construction site. People from the building and from the job site were trapped. Chief of Department John Esposito said one company was already in the neighborhood, drove onto the scene, and pulled people from the damaged building next door.

The walk-up held four apartments over a ground-floor store. It slid into the hole and tore the party wall off 1323 Flatbush Avenue, leaving a stairway, a closet of clothes, and a bedroom open to the street. The city vacated 1323, 1325, and 1327 Flatbush Avenue until inspectors could say those houses would stand.

James Williams, who works at a deli across the street, said he heard loud banging from the job site through the day, then saw bricks falling from the adjoining building. “Two minutes later, the building collapsed,” he said. Antione Vines said he watched from his room. “You could hear it.”

Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani said the crew was doing excavation work and digging down. The lot had an approved plan for a three-story building. It also had current plans for a nine-story building that had not been approved. The taller scheme is irrelevant to what stood on November 11, because no new building had gone up. The hole had.

NYCEM and the Red Cross opened a reception center at the Flatbush YMCA at 1401 Flatbush Avenue. As of 6 a.m. on November 12, the Red Cross had registered seven households, 14 adults and five children, for emergency help, including temporary lodging.

A Poor North Wall Beside an Open Pit

A geotechnical report done for the Bedford lot said adjoining buildings on the lot line would need underpinning. It warned that digging and construction vibration could hurt those structures and called for movement, crack, and vibration monitoring. Engineer Jieming Wang of LMW Engineering Group later answered Buildings Department questions on the support-of-excavation filing, including how soil loss would be controlled behind timber lagging.

It is expected that the adjoining buildings abutting the lot line would need underpinning. The required depth of underpinning and the condition of existing foundation may be obtained by excavating test pits next to the respective buildings.

Project geotechnical report, support-of-excavation file for 2625 Bedford Avenue

A required preconstruction survey on March 5 documented visible cracking at 1321 Flatbush Avenue. It rated the north masonry facade “Poor” and the west and east facades “Fair.” The survey said detailed information about the foundation type had not been provided. Drawings labeled the bottom of the excavation at 15.60 feet. Approved support-of-excavation plans called for steel soldier piles, timber lagging in lifts of no more than 2 feet, walers, rakers, and concrete deadmen, with optical surveys at least weekly once digging began.

WHAT THE BEDFORD FILE ALREADY SET DOWN

Item What the documents said
North facade, March 5 Poor, with noticeable cracks
West and east facades Fair, also with noticeable cracks
Underpinning Expected for buildings on the lot line
Building movement of 1/4 in. Immediate notice to the manager, owner, and engineer
Building movement of 1/2 in. Stop work until a fix is approved
Vibration above 3/4 in. per second, or a crack gauge over 2 mm Stop work
Special inspection of sheeting, shoring, and bracing Listed as identified but not certified in the DOB NOW records portal as of November 12

Those numbers do not, by themselves, prove a shoring failure. They do show that the city and the project engineer had already written down how close this work would come to a cracked 96-year-old wall. Available records still do not show whether 1321 Flatbush Avenue was underpinned, which pieces of the support system had been installed along that property line, or what the last gauge readings were before the fall.

The unbuilt nine-story version of the project leaned on a FRESH supermarket zoning bonus and a Universal Affordability Preference bonus, and it listed 64 apartments, 13 of them affordable. That paper tower did not dig the cellar. A three-story building with a cellar still needed a hole, and still needed the wall next door held up.

Why the March Stop-Work Order Did Not Hold

Inspectors stopped demolition on the Bedford lot on March 20 because neighboring properties lacked overhead protection. They came back on April 23, found demolition had resumed, and wrote another violation. They lifted the order on May 8 after the penalty was paid. That halt covered demolition of the old one-story commercial building, not the later excavation.

THE BEDFORD LOT CALENDAR

  1. March 5, 2026: Preconstruction survey rates the north wall of 1321 Flatbush Avenue poor.
  2. March 18, 2026: A 311 caller says demolition is underway without a permit and debris is flying.
  3. March 20, 2026: The Buildings Department issues a stop-work order for missing overhead protection.
  4. April 23, 2026: Inspectors find demolition has continued and the one-story building is fully down, and they issue another violation.
  5. May 8, 2026: The order is lifted after the civil penalty is paid; OATH penalties on the demolition total $12,500.
  6. June 2026: Certified letters go to neighboring owners, including the Flatbush landlord, saying excavation will start within 30 days.
  7. September 2026: Earthwork and support-of-excavation permits list Townhouse Builders as contractor; digging for the foundation is underway in the weeks before the collapse.
  8. November 11, 2026: 911 is called at 4:01 p.m. as 1321 Flatbush Avenue falls into the pit. A later 311 caller says the excavation did not follow the approved drawings.

N Tech Design of America was the demolition contractor cited for working through the March halt. A person from that firm later said the company had only done the demolition months earlier, not the digging on November 11. Townhouse Builders is listed as general contractor on the earthwork and support-of-excavation permits. Permit applications name Robert Fischman of W6 Facility X as owner. Cheng-Yi Lin Architecture is the architect of record. The Buildings Department has not tied the spring demolition violations to the November fall, and it has not closed the cause.

From the sidewalk, the hole did not look like a mystery. Neighbors had watched the lot for months. There were no 311 complaints on file about cracks, shaking, or vibration at either address from 2020 through the morning of November 11, which is a gap in the public warning system, not proof the wall was sound.

98 Open Violations Sat on the Housing File

City housing records list 98 open violations at 1321 Flatbush Avenue, a stock that stretches back to 1972. Isolag Realty Corp. is the owner of record. Olufemi Falade is listed as the company’s registered agent and signed the 2024 deed that moved the house into Isolag. Femi Realty Corp., also tied to Falade, had held the property since 1999.

Bedbugs and leaks do not pull a three-story building sideways into a pit. They do show how long the occupied house had been allowed to sit in poor repair while a crew dug next to it. Public Advocate Jumaane Williams said his office was looking into the owner and that Falade may have been on a worst-landlord watchlist in a recent year.

In 2006 a judge jailed Falade for 12 days for ignoring housing violations at three other Brooklyn buildings, at 1122 New York Avenue, 543 Madison Street, and 367 Tompkins Avenue, more than 600 violations in that case. 1321 Flatbush Avenue was not one of those three. The two files are separate, and both are now in front of investigators.

WHAT CITY HOUSING RECORDS LISTED AT 1321 FLATBUSH

  • Water and roof: Leaking ceilings and a leaking roof, including public-hall ceilings on the third story.
  • Wiring: Unsafe electrical wiring, including exposed wiring in a public hall.
  • Fire protection: Defective fire-retardant material and missing or broken smoke and carbon monoxide detectors.
  • Doors and pests: Defective doors, plus bedbug findings among the open items.
  • Sprinkler water: Repeated orders in recent years to provide adequate water supply for the sprinkler or standpipe system.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani said he was incredibly troubled to learn that cracks in the facade had already been written into the permitting file for the lot next door. A tragedy of this magnitude, he said, demands an investigation of both the construction site and the building that fell.

Who Died When the Building Came Down?

Eight people died, six in the wreckage and two later in hospitals. The NYPD named two children, 9 and 10 years old, and six adults. Two of the dead were construction workers. At least seven of the injured were children. Most of those still in the hospital were stable on Thursday; one person remained in critical condition.

THE EIGHT NAMED BY POLICE

Name Age What is known
Nicole Daniela Salvada Rodriguez 9 Child killed in the collapse
Kevin Santiago Reyes Gonzalez 10 Child killed in the collapse
Juan Daniel Salvada Guzman 31 Adult killed in the collapse
Ndiaye Mamadou 31 Lived in the building with his cousin; family from Guinea
Barry Mamadou 23 Cousin and roommate of Ndiaye Mamadou
Gabriel Siguencia 22 Construction worker from Ecuador; on the foundation crew about two weeks
Edgar Sapon 26 Adult killed in the collapse
Jose Luis Caguana Cosquillo 26 Construction worker from Ambato, Ecuador; father of a 4-year-old, wife pregnant

The Ecuadorian consul said Caguana Cosquillo and Gabriel Ariolfo Siguencia Yupa, the fuller name given for Siguencia, were among the dead. Luis Siguencia waited at the site for his son. “He wanted to get ahead. Because we all come here with the dream of getting ahead. He had his papers and everything.”

Segundo Iza grew up with Caguana Cosquillo in Ambato and had played soccer with him. “He was someone who came here to achieve many dreams, to find better days for our children and our parents,” Iza said. “So it’s sad that our friend died here in New York.” Caguana Cosquillo had been in the United States about six years. His pregnant wife is not the woman pulled from the apartments.

That woman was six months pregnant and lived with the Mamadou cousins. Firefighters brought her out on a stretcher around 6:30 p.m. Her husband, identified by neighbors as a native of Congo, had been held back by police when he tried to run into the pile. “I have an update. She is alive, she is still alive. I am very happy,” he said. Williams, the public advocate, stood with him on the sidewalk. Councilmember Farah Louis said Wednesday night that the woman was in critical condition. Officials did not name the person still critical on Thursday.

The Crew That Climbed Back Into the Pit

Construction workers were on the job when the building came down. Two of them died in it. Others lived, then went back into the rubble and pulled people out before the first-due companies had the pile organized.

Construction workers who had only barely survived themselves turned back and dug victims out of the rubble. People are alive today because of their heroism.

Zohran Mamdani, Mayor of New York City, at a Thursday press conference

Bonsignore had said Wednesday night that the count could change by the minute and that crews would look until they found everybody. On Thursday, with rain on the site and a grappler pulling clothing and metal from the heap, she said the work would not stop. “This type of an emergency is something our members train extensively for, and we will be here until we are one hundred percent sure there are no more people trapped,” she said. By late afternoon the FDNY had finished the search and turned the lot over to the Buildings Department and the police.

Assiah Bah, 23, waited through the night for news of two cousins who had been cooking dinner in the building. Katie Stevens, a teacher who lives down the block, heard what she first took for a car crash, then sirens, and found a family with a young boy on the sidewalk. He asked when he could go home. She did not know.

Mamdani Ordered Sweeps at About 100 Sites

The Buildings Department filed a full stop-work order on the Bedford lot the afternoon of the collapse. The order cited unsafe construction operations causing 1321 Flatbush Avenue to collapse to the ground and onto the construction site. Tigani said investigators were collecting photographs, video, and witness accounts. The Brooklyn District Attorney’s office is part of the inquiry.

Mamdani said five entities involved in the construction site are tied to about 100 other sites across the city. “Our Department of Buildings is commencing sweeps of those sites today,” he said on Thursday. He did not name the five. “If there is anyone or any entity operating in this city that bears responsibility for what happened, we will hold them fully accountable.”

Some of the political argument around the lot has attached itself to the unapproved nine-story filing and to city housing bonuses. The permit record does not back that shortcut. The approved work was excavation and foundation for a three-story building with a cellar. The taller scheme had not been approved, and no superstructure was up. The live questions sit in the hole, the gauges, and the wall that had already been rated poor.

WHAT WE KNOW

  • The search: The FDNY closed a roughly 24-hour operation on November 12 with eight dead and 18 injured.
  • The work underway: Excavation was active at 2625 Bedford Avenue when 1321 Flatbush Avenue fell into the pit.
  • The paper trail: A March survey called the north wall poor; drawings set movement stop-points; a spring stop-work order on demolition was lifted on May 8.
  • The new halt: The Buildings Department’s November 11 stop-work order cites unsafe construction operations as causing the neighboring collapse.

WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED

  • The failure mode: Officials have not said whether underpinning was installed, whether gauges tripped, or how the wall lost its bearing.
  • The five entities: The mayor has not released the list of companies or the 100 addresses now under sweep.
  • Criminal charges: The district attorney is involved; no charges have been announced.

Mamdani said the building had been home to several immigrant families. The special inspection of excavation sheeting, shoring, and bracing was still listed as identified, not certified, on November 12. That status does not prove the inspection never happened. It does mean the city’s own portal, the day after eight people died, still could not show it complete.

Harry is the editor and publisher of MY WORLD NEWS 24, an independent title under his own ownership. Ten years of reporting and then editing taught him that a global readership is not served by assuming everyone lives in the same country. Stories here state currencies, units and time zones explicitly, name the country a law or a company belongs to, and explain local context rather than treating it as known. That care extends to sourcing: a claim is anchored to the filing, statement, transcript or dataset that made it, wherever in the world it was issued, and each figure is checked against that source before publication. The site reports news, business and technology, science and sports, entertainment, lifestyle and travel, and auto and gaming, all with the same standard of evidence. Mistakes are fixed under a corrections policy anyone can read, and the page carries a note saying what was changed. Harry reads every message sent by readers and replies from support@myworldnews24.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending