Connect with us

NEWS

Egypt Closes Mada Masr After Eight Years Without a Permit

A Cairo court used Egypt’s 2018 website-license law, the statute Mada Masr spent eight years trying to satisfy.

Published

on

A Cairo court on October 27 fined Mada Masr editor Lina Attalah LE3 million ($53,400) and ordered the independent news site closed. The New Cairo Misdemeanor Court also ordered the confiscation of the outlet’s equipment for running a website without a license.

Security officers surrounded Attalah, lifted her off the ground, and carried her from the courtroom. She was released several hours later, after the newsroom paid the fine in full. The statute used against her is the 2018 media law Mada Masr has spent eight years trying to satisfy.

The Judge Wrote the Substitute Lawyer’s Requests Himself

The ninth circuit, with Judge Mohamed Mubarak presiding, convicted her of managing an unlicensed website at the first hearing. Defense lawyers asked for time to read the case file. The judge paused, then had the room cleared of everyone except Attalah, her counsel, and Hossam Bahgat, executive director of the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights, who was sitting in.

Plainclothes officers and guards filled the space. A National Security Agency officer was in the room, Bahgat told the newsroom. The judge and a Supreme State Security Prosecution representative came back and said every procedural request was refused, including the right to put papers in the file and to call witnesses.

Counsel declined to plead while those requests sat unanswered. The judge then called in a lawyer none of the defense team knew and said the court would appoint that person for Attalah. Eight of her own lawyers were already there. Attalah said she did not accept the appointment. The judge refused to put her objection in the minutes.

INSIDE THE NEW CAIRO COURTROOM

  1. File review: The defense asked for time to read the papers and was refused.
  2. The room: Observers were cleared out; plainclothes officers and a National Security Agency officer came in.
  3. The substitute: The judge appointed a lawyer unknown to the eight counsel already present, over Attalah’s objection.
  4. The minutes: The judge wrote that lawyer’s requests himself, Bahgat said, before the lawyer had spoken.
  5. The penalty: A LE3 million fine, closure of the site, and confiscation, the ceiling under the charge.

Bahgat, who watched the sequence, said the judge then logged the substitute’s requests without the man having said a word, and read the conviction over shouts from the defense. Lobna Darwish, advocacy director at the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights, whose lawyers sat on the team, told the Committee to Protect Journalists the hearing “lacked the most basic rules of a fair trial.”

In an even more shocking move, the judge himself began to log down the requests of the court-appointed lawyer, without the lawyer having said a word.

Hossam Bahgat, executive director, Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights, to Mada Masr

The newsroom posted the courtroom account from Cairo while Attalah was still in the building.

Hassan al-Azhari, Mada Masr’s lawyer, said the newsroom would appeal the closure. Khaled el-Balshy, head of the Journalists’ Syndicate, said the union would take legal action against the ruling. Ahead of the sitting, the syndicate had already sent the Supreme Council for Media Regulation a memorandum asking for a reasoned decision on the license file and for an end to criminal cases built on that file.

Eight Years of License Paperwork Never Produced a Permit

Egypt’s 2018 Press and Media Regulation Law, Law No. 180, requires websites to hold a license from the Supreme Council for Media Regulation. Mada Masr, founded in 2013, filed when the council called on sites to regularize their status in October 2018 and paid a LE50,000 fee. The law gives the council 90 days to accept or refuse and to notify the applicant so a refusal can be challenged.

No answer came. After the executive regulations were issued in 2020, the newsroom sent a letter in August of that year with a copy of the original filing, saying it still wanted the application heard. Silence again. Attalah first saw a rejection letter on September 7, 2022, when prosecutors questioned her over a political-party corruption story and charged her with running a site without a license. The letter was dated January 3, 2021.

The outlet sued in the Court of Administrative Justice on October 11, 2022, asking for a license and for damages because the council had not given notice inside the legal window. In a March 2023 hearing, a lawyer for the council set out reasons that had not been sent to the company: that the only filing was in 2020, that trademark proof was missing, that some papers were “not valid,” and that commercial-registry shareholder papers were absent, even though Mada Masr is not a joint stock company. The council said a notice to the registered address came back, and that Attalah had signed a refusal in person before the secretary general. She denied that.

On May 24, 2023, the sixth anniversary of the extra-legal block on the site, the challenge was turned down by an administrative court. Al-Azhari said he had put a trademark registration certificate in the file. The law allows a fresh application, and Mada Masr filed one in June 2023 with the extra papers the council had listed. That file was still unanswered when the misdemeanor court closed the site. On December 19, 2023, the Supreme Administrative Court blocked an appeal of the May ruling and gave no reasons.

THE LICENSE FILE

Date What the newsroom filed What came back
October 2018 License application and LE50,000 fee No decision inside 90 days
August 2020 Letter restating the 2018 request No reply
January 3, 2021 Council rejection (dated that day) Shown to Attalah on September 7, 2022
October 11, 2022 Administrative lawsuit for a license Rejected May 24, 2023
June 2023 New application with extra papers Still pending on October 27, 2026
December 19, 2023 Appeal to the Supreme Administrative Court Blocked, no reasons given

Access to the site inside Egypt was cut on May 24, 2017, among a first wave of blocked news pages, without a published administrative order the company could appeal on the merits. A separate 2017 lawsuit over that block was sent to ministry experts in 2018; Mada Masr said those findings were never made public. The October 27 order is a different instrument. It is a criminal court’s command to close the site and seize devices, sitting on top of a block that had already been in place for readers in Egypt.

Bassam Khawaja, deputy Middle East and North Africa director at Human Rights Watch, said Egyptian authorities should drop the case. He argued that setting registration rules and then ignoring good faith attempts to fulfill them is a way to keep an outlet in legal jeopardy, and that it violates international human rights law.

What the 2018 Media Law Does to an Unlicensed Site

Article 6 of the law says no website may be established or run in Egypt, and no office of a foreign site may be run, without a license from the council. Bylaws route each file through a committee, the telecom regulator, and what the rules call “the concerned agencies.” The council decides. Operating without that paper is a crime.

Article 105 then sets the bill. Anyone who violates Articles 6, 41, 59, or 67 faces a fine of no less than LE1 million and no more than LE3 million. The court must also order closure and confiscation of the equipment, devices, and components used in the offense. On a repeat, both ends of the fine double. Most other fines in the same law sit between LE50,000 and LE1 million. The unlicensed-site charge is the one that starts at a million.

That is the charge the Supreme State Security Prosecution put in Case No. 9072/2026 after questioning Attalah on October 21. Prosecutors had summoned her on October 19. They held her for more than six hours over the license and over a Mada Masr report on a wave of prison protests, then released her on LE100,000 bail, about $1,780. A separate “false news” allegation from that interrogation was not sent to the misdemeanor court. Referral came on October 22. The verdict came five days later, in Case No. 11743 of 2026, at the first sitting.

Sara Qudah, regional director at the Committee to Protect Journalists, said putting Attalah in custody and ordering the newsroom shut “is a direct message aimed at dismantling independent media in the country.” Yasmine Ahmed, Amnesty International’s senior director for regional impact, called the ruling “the culmination of years of relentless harassment and unjust proceedings designed to shut down one of the country’s last remaining independent media voices.” More than a hundred civil society groups had already asked the state to stop the prosecution and grant the license.

There was no immediate comment from the government, the council, or the Public Prosecutor’s Office. The prosecutor’s office did not answer a Committee to Protect Journalists query on the legal basis for holding Attalah until the fine was paid, on the refusal of documents and witnesses, and on the exclusion of a Journalists’ Syndicate representative from the hearing. Defense lawyers said journalists and international observers were kept out of the critical stages.

Matsadaash’s Entire Newsroom Is Still in Pretrial Detention

The same Tuesday, Egypt’s Supreme State Security Prosecution renewed the detention of six journalists from the fact-checking platform Matsadaash for another 15 days. They are Mohamed Ashraf Abu Omeira, Abdallah Kadry, Islam Barakat, Omar Helal, Mohamed Adel, and Mohamed Mahmoud, the platform’s full editorial team. They face Case No. 8083 of 2026 on charges of joining and financing a terrorist group, spreading false news, and using a social media account to promote it. They deny the charges.

National Security Agency officers arrested them on September 28 and 29 in several governorates, seized phones and computers, and held them incommunicado for days. The Interior Ministry on October 1 described the platform as an unlicensed page run from abroad. Lawyers only reached their clients when the six were brought individually to the Supreme State Security Prosecution around October 3 and 4. Questioning, rights lawyers said, ran to their reporting, prior jobs, how they joined the platform, and its editorial line.

The six have said they were beaten, given electric shocks, and threatened, and that they were pressed to record statements against themselves while in National Security Agency custody. The Public Prosecution has denied torture claims. Five of them, held in Badr 1 prison, have asked for more outdoor time and for visits equal to those of other detainees. A first 15-day remand was renewed on October 13. The October 27 extension was the second.

Attalah’s own October file sits in that same month. Human Rights Watch recorded a further summons of independent journalist Rasha Azab over social media posts. Mada Masr has said this license case is the sixth brought against the outlet or its journalists in six years, and rights groups say it is the first of those to reach a trial verdict. Prosecutors had already questioned Attalah in August 2025 over a report on alleged abuses at Badr 3 prison, on false-news and unlicensed-site allegations, and released her on bail then as well.

Attalah Learns of a 2024 Prison Term at Release

Paying the October 27 fine ended the custody that followed the misdemeanor verdict. It did not end Attalah’s exposure. During the release paperwork, she was told a court had sentenced her in absentia in 2024 to one year in prison, plus a LE20,000 fine, for publishing false news and running an unlicensed website. Al-Azhari said the defense filed an opposition to that judgment. A retrial hearing is set for November 11.

That 2024 file is a separate case from the LE3 million ruling. The new hearing will test whether a sentence entered without her in the room will be replaced after she has now been found, fined, and processed on a later version of the same license charge. The October 27 judgment itself is a first-instance misdemeanor ruling and can be appealed, which is the path the syndicate and al-Azhari said they would take.

THE OCTOBER CALENDAR

  1. October 19, 2026: State security prosecutors summon Attalah for investigation.
  2. October 21, 2026: She is questioned for more than six hours and released on LE100,000 bail.
  3. October 22, 2026: Prosecutors refer her to trial on the unlicensed-site charge in Case No. 9072/2026.
  4. October 27, 2026: The misdemeanor court issues the maximum penalty; Matsadaash’s six journalists have their detention renewed for 15 days.
  5. November 11, 2026: A retrial hearing is listed on the 2024 in-absentia sentence.

Sharif Abdel Kouddous, a journalist who spent four years at Mada Masr, called the October 27 sitting “a sham proceeding” and said the newsroom’s lawyers were handed the file in court and denied time to review it. The sequence from summons to maximum penalty ran eight days. The license applications behind that penalty have run since 2018.

Egypt Now Holds 25 Journalists Behind Bars

The Committee to Protect Journalists said that as of late October, 25 journalists are behind bars in Egypt, the highest number since 2021. Its 2025 annual prison census had listed 18. Qudah said that if the state can jail one of its most watched editors and shut her newsroom, “no independent journalist in the country is safe.”

PRESSURE ON EGYPTIAN NEWSROOMS

  • The fine: LE3 million, the top figure in Article 105, paid in full on October 27 to secure Attalah’s release.
  • The jail count: 25 journalists imprisoned in late October 2026, up from 18 in the 2025 census.
  • The block: Mada Masr unreachable on Egyptian internet service since May 24, 2017, now also under a court closure order.
  • The other newsroom: Six Matsadaash journalists in pretrial detention on terrorism and false-news charges after arrests on September 28 and 29.

Leopoldo Maldonado, the UN special rapporteur on freedom of opinion and expression, said on October 28 that Egyptian authorities should reverse measures that unduly restrict Mada Masr’s work and release journalists held for their reporting. He pointed to the 25 still in prison and to the closing of outlets as a shrinking space that “requires urgent attention.”

Mada Masr built its reputation on investigations into corruption, the military’s economic role, and rights abuses, publishing in Arabic and English from Cairo while most newspapers and television stations sit close to the state. Readers inside the country have needed workarounds since 2017. The October 27 order goes further than a block. It treats the newsroom’s devices as crime tools and the editor as the operator of an illegal site, even as a June 2023 license file sits unanswered at the council that is supposed to issue permits.

Faith in the Law Did Not Survive the Hearing

Hours after the verdict, Mada Masr published an editorial saying it had gone into court “with a measure of faith in the law and the justice system.” It added, “But what we found in court left none of that faith intact.” The editorial said the judge appointed “an unknown party” even though eight of Attalah’s lawyers were present, wrote that lawyer’s requests himself, and issued “a verdict carrying the maximum penalty, with no review and no defence.”

We tried to defend the law, just as we tried to defend ourselves.

Mada Masr, editorial after the October 27, 2026 verdict

The hearing did not invent the license problem. It cashed it. A newsroom that paid the 2018 fee, mailed a 2020 reminder, sued in 2022, lost in 2023, and filed again that June was told, at the first criminal sitting, that the absence of the paper it had been requesting was now a completed crime. The June 2023 application still had no answer when the court closed the site. The retrial on the 2024 sentence is listed for November 11.

Harry is the editor and publisher of MY WORLD NEWS 24, an independent title under his own ownership. Ten years of reporting and then editing taught him that a global readership is not served by assuming everyone lives in the same country. Stories here state currencies, units and time zones explicitly, name the country a law or a company belongs to, and explain local context rather than treating it as known. That care extends to sourcing: a claim is anchored to the filing, statement, transcript or dataset that made it, wherever in the world it was issued, and each figure is checked against that source before publication. The site reports news, business and technology, science and sports, entertainment, lifestyle and travel, and auto and gaming, all with the same standard of evidence. Mistakes are fixed under a corrections policy anyone can read, and the page carries a note saying what was changed. Harry reads every message sent by readers and replies from support@myworldnews24.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending