BUSINESS
Judge Vacates Extra Medicaid Frailty Test, Leaves Other Limits
A Boston judge vacated CMS’s extra Medicaid frailty test, but a 12-month claims cutoff and a one-attestation cap still govern exemptions as work rules near.
U.S. District Judge Richard G. Stearns on October 29 vacated a federal test that required chronically ill Medicaid adults to prove they cannot work. The extra hurdle sat on top of five medical categories Congress already wrote into a 2025 law. Work, school, and volunteering rules for expansion adults still take effect January 1, 2027.
The order, in Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz, cuts a clause the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services added in June. What remains is the paperwork CMS still uses to see who is “medically frail,” and a statutory clock that Stearns said he cannot move.
Judge Stearns Vacates CMS’s Extra Frailty Test
Stearns, sitting in Boston, ruled on cross-motions for summary judgment in a suit filed June 29 by 25 states and the District of Columbia. The defendants are CMS Director Mehmet Oz, CMS, Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., and HHS. His 16-page summary judgment order finds that CMS went past the statute when it defined a medically frail person as someone in one of Congress’s five groups whose condition also “significantly impairs the individual’s ability to comply with the community engagement requirement.”
That second test is in 42 C.F.R. § 435.554(c)(5)(i), issued in an interim final rule on June 3, 2026. H.R. 1, signed July 4, 2025, told the secretary to define “medically frail or otherwise has special medical needs,” and then listed groups the term must include. Stearns held the listed groups are examples of what Congress meant. CMS could not add a work-capacity filter on top of them. He called the extra limit beyond the agency’s powers and contrary to law under the Administrative Procedure Act, then vacated the offending language so the rest of the rule could stand.
Because enforcement of an unlawful definition of “medically frail” may lead to the disenrollment of otherwise eligible vulnerable individuals relying on Medicaid coverage for continuity of care, the States (and public) face potential for great hardship in the absence of an injunction.
U.S. District Judge Richard G. Stearns, memorandum and order, District of Massachusetts
He also issued the permanent injunction the states asked for. Informal CMS advice to states, he wrote, never tied medical frailty to an ability to meet the work rule. The June rule did, and states that had already built exemption screens around the statute had to rebuild them around impairment.
Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell co-led the case with California Attorney General Rob Bonta and New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport. Campbell said the order protects access to healthcare for residents with serious illnesses and disabilities and keeps their care from being cut by “unlawful red tape.” Dr. Willie Underwood III, president of the American Medical Association, called the decision a victory for patients and said they should not have to clear hurdles Congress did not write. CMS did not immediately comment.
The 12-Month Claims Window Survives
The states also attacked two verification limits. Stearns left both in place. He found the government’s reasons non-frivolous and said the states had not shown the limits were arbitrary under the APA. The extra impairment test is gone. The file CMS will still let states use is not.
THREE CHALLENGES IN MASSACHUSETTS V. OZ
| CMS rule the states challenged | What it required | October 29 result |
|---|---|---|
| Extra impairment test | A qualifying condition must also significantly impair the ability to meet the work rule | Vacated as contrary to law; permanently enjoined |
| Claims lookback | Only the prior 12 months of claims and encounter data count as reliable | Upheld |
| Self-attestation cap | States may accept one self-attestation per continuous enrollment period | Upheld |
KFF’s briefing on the June rule says states must first try claims data from the preceding 12 months before asking a person for more. CMS told states that older records “may not reflect the individual’s current condition.” That logic is a poor fit for a spinal injury, a stable psychiatric diagnosis, or cancer treatment that has moved off the hospital floor. A quiet year of managed disease can look like health in a claims extract, even after the impairment test is gone.
The self-attestation cap bites in a different way. Under the rule Stearns upheld, a person gets one sworn statement per continuous stretch of coverage. KFF notes that states may lean on self-attestation through 2027 when they have no reliable file, then, starting January 1, 2028, may accept it only once during an enrollment period. A member who attests on the basis of cancer and later develops a separate disabling condition cannot attest again while still enrolled. The next step is paper from a clinic, or a gap in coverage.
States must also recheck medically frail status at least every 12 months, even when the underlying condition is unlikely to change. That reverification cycle is separate from the 12-month claims window. Both survived.
January 1 Still Governs the Work Rules
At an October 22 hearing, the states said they were not asking the court to push back the date Congress set. Stearns wrote that he would be powerless to grant that relief in any event. Vacatur, he said, gives the parties a clean text to code against before January 1, 2027, which falls 64 days after the order.
He did grant a six-month stay of enforcement on determinations that a person does or does not qualify as medically frail under H.R. 1. A footnote states that the stay does not touch the statutory start date. Campbell’s office described it as time for the plaintiff states to absorb errors and delays in the first months of rollout. Work, school, and volunteering checks can still begin in January. What is paused is CMS enforcement around the frailty call itself.
WHAT WE KNOW
- The extra test: The “significantly impairs” clause is vacated nationwide as part of the interim final rule and is under a permanent injunction.
- The leftover gates: The 12-month claims window and the one-attestation cap remain in the rule.
- The calendar: Expansion adults ages 19 to 64 in covered states still face the work rule on January 1, 2027, unless they fall in a statutory exemption.
WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED
- An appeal: CMS has not said whether it will ask the First Circuit to restore the impairment test.
- Non-plaintiff states: The stay is written for the states that sued; how other Medicaid agencies rewrite their screens is not spelled out in the order.
- Code lists: States still owe CMS auditable lists of qualifying diagnoses, and it is not yet public how those lists change once impairment is no longer a required element.
On July 29, Stearns had denied a preliminary injunction. He found then that CMS’s promise to reimburse 90% of systems costs kept the states’ money harm below the bar for emergency relief. The October opinion treats a different injury. Once the definition is unlawful, he wrote, the states face costly changes to eligibility systems, and eligible people face lost coverage that money cannot repair.
Who Counts as Medically Frail Under the Law
H.R. 1 makes Medicaid eligibility for “applicable individuals,” mainly adults added under the Affordable Care Act expansion, turn on a community engagement rule beginning January 1, 2027. KFF’s read of the statute is that those adults must complete 80 hours of work or community service a month, or be in school at least half time, unless they are a “specified excluded individual.” Medically frail people are in that excluded group. So are pregnant and postpartum people, and parents or caretakers of children 13 and under, among others.
The statute does not leave the frailty category blank. It says the term includes five groups, and Stearns treated those groups as the floor CMS had to honor.
FIVE GROUPS CONGRESS SAID TO INCLUDE
- Blind or disabled: People who meet the Social Security Act definitions in 42 U.S.C. § 1382c.
- Substance use disorder: The June rule still says the category applies whether or not the person is in active treatment, and it excludes people in active recovery for 5 or more years, a limit the October order did not disturb.
- Disabling mental disorder: Congress used “disabling,” and CMS left states to map that word onto diagnosis codes.
- Daily-living disability: A physical, intellectual, or developmental disability that significantly impairs one or more activities of daily living. That impairment language is in the statute itself, and it is about daily living, not about the 80 hours work test.
- Serious or complex medical condition: CMS had defined this as a high-acuity subset. Without the extra work-impairment filter, a qualifying diagnosis can carry the exemption even if the person still holds a job.
KFF counts 44 states that must condition expansion or waiver coverage on the work rule, including Georgia, Tennessee, and Wisconsin, which cover some adults through waivers rather than a full ACA expansion. As of June 2024, more than 20 million people were on expansion coverage. States have to look back at least one month before an application and at least one month between six-month renewals. If they cannot verify work or an exemption, they send a 30-day notice. Coverage can be denied or ended after that window. People who lose Medicaid for failing the work rule are also barred from subsidized Marketplace plans under the same law.
State Systems Must Rework Exemption Screens
The irreparable harm Stearns named first was not a patient vignette. It was “costly and intensive alterations to their eligibility verification systems.” That is the part of the case the headline fight over sick people tends to skip, and it is the part state agencies still have to finish.
FROM THE 2025 LAW TO THE ORDER
- July 4, 2025: President Trump signs H.R. 1, setting a January 1, 2027 start for community engagement and ordering an interim final rule by June 1, 2026.
- June 3, 2026: CMS publishes the interim final rule at 91 Fed. Reg. 33348, adding the impairment test, the 12-month claims limit, and the attestation cap.
- June 29, 2026: Massachusetts, California, New Jersey, and 22 other states plus D.C. sue in Boston. Kentucky and Pennsylvania appear through their governors.
- July 29, 2026: Stearns denies a preliminary injunction without prejudice, citing the 90% federal share of systems costs.
- October 22, 2026: The court hears summary judgment. The states say they are not seeking a later start date.
- October 29, 2026: The court vacates the impairment language, enjoins it, upholds the two verification limits, and grants the six-month stay on frailty determinations.
Optional federal advice issued in September had offered states a three-tier screen. In the first tier, diagnosis codes alone could establish frailty. In the second, codes had to be paired with hospital use, high-risk drug lists, or durable medical equipment. The third was a manual review. That stack assumed CMS could demand proof of impairment. After October 29, a diagnosis in one of the five statutory groups is supposed to be enough. Agencies that already coded the middle tier into their eligibility engines now have to pull that logic out without missing the January start, and without tripping audits on their diagnosis lists.
Nebraska began work rules on May 1, 2026, the first state to go early. Iowa has said it will start December 1. Everyone else on the expansion and waiver list is aimed at January 1. KFF has warned that claims files miss functional limits and behavioral health, and that asking treating clinicians to certify an inability to work, as New Hampshire once did, produced resistance from primary care offices. The leftover 12-month window keeps that pressure in place. People who already proved their conditions to get on Medicaid can still be asked to prove them again through a recent bill.
CBO Already Put a Price on Coverage Loss
The Congressional Budget Office scored the work rule as the largest Medicaid saver in the 2025 package. KFF’s analysis of those figures puts federal savings from the mandate at $326 billion over ten years, out of $911 billion in Medicaid cuts from 2025 through 2034. Earlier CBO estimates of the law’s Medicaid changes found enrollment would fall by more than 11 million and the number of people without insurance would rise by 7.5 million in 2034. CBO has not published a fresh coverage estimate that folds in the June rule.
THE COVERAGE STAKES IN THE 2025 LAW
- Work-rule savings: $326 billion in lower federal Medicaid outlays over ten years, per KFF’s analysis of CBO.
- Package total: $911 billion in federal Medicaid reductions from 2025 through 2034.
- Uninsured: 7.5 million more people without insurance in 2034, from CBO’s earlier Medicaid-package estimate.
- Arkansas precedent: About 18,000 people lost coverage the last time a state ran a similar work rule, KFF notes, many of them eligible people who did not complete the forms.
CBO has also said a Medicaid work rule does not raise the share of enrollees who hold jobs. The coverage loss comes from the reporting. That is the residue Stearns left on the table. He took away CMS’s extra demand that a qualifying illness also block an 80-hour month. He left a claims window that can hide a stable disease, a cap that spends a person’s one attestation on the first diagnosis, and a start date 64 days out. State systems still have to decide whose file looks frail enough to keep.
Disclaimer: This article is news reporting on a federal court order and on Medicaid eligibility rules. It is informational only and is not legal, medical, or benefits advice. It does not determine whether any person qualifies for a medically frail exemption, how a state will apply the leftover verification limits, or how to enroll or stay enrolled. Readers with questions about their own coverage should contact their state Medicaid agency or a benefits counselor, and should consult a licensed attorney about the effect of the order. Figures and case status reflect the court record and the research cited here and may change if an appeals court acts or if CMS issues new guidance.
-
BUSINESS3 months agoWarsh Rejects Rate Guidance and Still Moves Markets
-
ENTERTAINMENT1 month agoDavina McCall Reveals Cardiovascular Disease After Cholesterol Warnings
-
BUSINESS2 months agoDana-Farber Exits an MGB Medicare Advantage Network Early
-
NEWS3 months agoNASA Launches the Roman Space Telescope’s Cosmic Bet
-
NEWS3 months agoOpenAI’s Cyber Letter Puts the Defense Bill on Governments
-
NEWS3 months agoRussia Recycles Its Old Warning Over Storm Shadow Plants
-
ENTERTAINMENT2 months agoPrimetime’s $2.7 Million Preview Tops Pitt’s Costlier Film
-
BUSINESS3 months agoJet Drones Lock Down Kyiv and Strip Kherson of Heat
